A sustainability claim is only as strong as the evidence behind it.

A product can contain recycled material and still have a significant carbon footprint. A manufacturer can reduce its emissions without necessarily producing a lower-carbon product than its competitors. And a sustainability claim can be technically correct but still create a misleading impression.

That's what makes credible sustainability communication more complicated than simply having good intentions. The real question isn't just whether a claim is true. It's whether the evidence supports the impression you're creating.

Being more sustainable isn't the same as proving it

Businesses are under increasing pressure to demonstrate the environmental performance of their products and services. Customers want credible information. Procurement teams want evidence. Regulators are scrutinising environmental claims more closely.

Under Australian Consumer Law, sustainability claims must not be false or misleading. The ACCC's greenwashing guidance reinforces the importance of accurate, specific and evidence-based claims. But this doesn't mean businesses should stop communicating sustainability achievements.It means understanding exactly what the evidence demonstrates and being clear about what it doesn't.

Recycled content doesn't automatically mean lower carbon

This is particularly relevant in manufacturing and construction, where recycled content and embodied carbon are increasingly important purchasing considerations. A product containing recycled materials may have environmental benefits, but that doesn't automatically mean it has a lower carbon footprint. Manufacturing processes, energy sources, transport and material choices all influence embodied carbon.

Similarly, a product with a verified carbon footprint isn't necessarily a 'low-carbon product'. That depends on what it's being compared with, the methodology used and whether the comparison is appropriate. These distinctions matter because environmental claims can influence purchasing decisions.

From marketing claims to credible product data

Through work supporting verified product carbon footprints in the built environment, we've seen growing demand for more specific and transparent environmental information. Manufacturers increasingly need to provide product-level carbon data that architects, builders and procurement teams can use to compare options and make informed decisions.

Tools such as product carbon footprints (PCFs), lifecycle assessments (LCAs) and Environmental Product Declarations (EPDs) provide important evidence. But having the data is only part of the equation.

Businesses also need to understand what the data means, its limitations and how it can be communicated. For example, a carbon footprint calculated for the manufacturing stages of a product shouldn't be presented as representing its entire lifecycle. And a claim that a product has 30% lower embodied carbon needs a credible, clearly defined comparison. The strongest sustainability communications make these distinctions clear.

Evidence first. Communications second.

Too often, sustainability claims are developed at the end of a project, when the marketing team is asked to communicate the benefits. A better approach is to consider the evidence from the beginning. What are we trying to demonstrate? How will it be measured? What verification is needed? And what can we credibly communicate?

This requires collaboration between sustainability, technical, legal and communications teams. It also creates an opportunity to tell a more compelling story. Specific, measurable achievements are often more meaningful than broad environmental promises. And being transparent about limitations doesn't necessarily weaken a claim. It can strengthen credibility.

The strongest sustainability claim isn't necessarily the boldest. It's the one you can confidently stand behind.

Previous
Previous

Sustainability training should drive action, not just awareness.

Next
Next

A sustainability strategy is only as good as its implementation.